Modifier AY- Non-ESRD Item or Service

Modifier AY identifies an item or service furnished to an ESRD patient that is not related to the treatment of ESRD.

Home > All Categories > Medicare Modifiers > Modifier AY

What is Modifier AY?

Modifier AY identifies an item or service furnished to a patient with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) when that item or service is not provided for the treatment of ESRD.

The distinction is important because Medicare's ESRD Prospective Payment System includes many renal dialysis services within a bundled payment to the ESRD facility. When an otherwise separately payable item or service is furnished for a medical condition unrelated to ESRD treatment, Modifier AY communicates that distinction on the claim.

Modifier AY does not automatically make an item or service separately payable. The service must genuinely be unrelated to ESRD treatment and independently satisfy applicable Medicare coverage, medical necessity, coding, and documentation requirements.

When to Use Modifier AY

Service Is Unrelated to ESRD Treatment: Modifier AY may be appropriate when an ESRD patient receives an eligible item or service for a condition that is unrelated to the treatment of ESRD.

Separate Medical Condition: The patient has another illness, injury, or condition requiring medically necessary care that is not part of managing ESRD or furnishing renal dialysis services.

Item Is Outside ESRD Treatment: An eligible item furnished to an ESRD beneficiary may support AY when its purpose is unrelated to the patient's renal dialysis treatment.

Separate Payment May Apply: AY may help identify an otherwise payable item or service as outside the ESRD bundled payment when applicable Medicare requirements are satisfied.

Documentation Establishes the Distinction: The medical record should clearly demonstrate why the reported item or service is unrelated to ESRD treatment.

When NOT to Use Modifier AY

Item or Service Is Related to ESRD: Do not report AY when the service is furnished for the treatment or management of ESRD.

Renal Dialysis Service: Services that constitute renal dialysis services and are included in the applicable ESRD payment methodology should not be characterized as unrelated simply to seek separate reimbursement.

ESRD Patient Status Alone: The fact that a beneficiary has ESRD does not mean every separately reported service requires AY. The modifier should be used only when applicable billing requirements call for identifying the service as unrelated to ESRD treatment.

Documentation Does Not Establish an Unrelated Purpose: AY should not be reported when the medical record does not clearly support why the item or service is separate from ESRD treatment.

To Bypass Bundling Rules: Modifier AY should never be used solely to obtain separate payment for an item or service that belongs within the ESRD payment bundle.

Billing Example

A Medicare beneficiary with ESRD receives regular renal dialysis services. The patient also requires an eligible medically necessary service for a separate condition that is unrelated to the patient's kidney disease or dialysis treatment.

The provider determines that the service is not a renal dialysis service and that applicable Medicare billing requirements support separate reporting.

The appropriate code is submitted with Modifier AY to communicate that the service was furnished to an ESRD patient but was not for the treatment of ESRD.

The medical record should clearly document the separate condition and establish why the reported service was unrelated to ESRD treatment.

Documentation Requirements

Unrelated Condition: Clearly document the medical condition, injury, or clinical circumstance requiring the item or service.

Relationship to ESRD: Documentation should establish why the reported service is not related to the treatment or management of the patient's ESRD.

Service Performed: Maintain complete documentation describing the item, procedure, treatment, or other service furnished.

Medical Necessity: The record should independently support why the unrelated item or service was reasonable and necessary.

Diagnosis Information: Diagnosis coding should accurately represent the condition being treated and remain consistent with the documented reason for reporting AY.

Claim Consistency: The procedure code, diagnoses, modifier, dates of service, and medical record should consistently demonstrate that the service was unrelated to ESRD treatment.

Billing and Claim Considerations

Modifier AY is particularly important because Medicare's ESRD Prospective Payment System incorporates numerous renal dialysis services into a bundled payment. Correctly identifying whether an item or service is related to ESRD treatment can therefore affect whether separate payment is considered.

Providers should evaluate the clinical purpose of the service, not merely where or when it was furnished. A service performed during the same period in which a patient receives dialysis can still be unrelated to ESRD when documentation supports a separate medical reason.

Conversely, an item or service closely connected to dialysis or ESRD management should not be reported with AY simply because separate billing would produce additional reimbursement.

Modifier AY does not override Medicare coverage rules. The underlying service must still qualify for coverage and satisfy applicable medical necessity and documentation requirements.

Common Billing Mistakes

Using AY for ESRD-Related Services: Reporting AY on an item or service that actually contributes to the patient's dialysis or ESRD treatment can result in incorrect separate payment.

Assuming Every Non-Dialysis Service Requires AY: An ESRD diagnosis alone does not automatically require AY on every other Medicare claim for the beneficiary.

Using AY to Avoid Bundled Payment: The modifier should reflect the true clinical purpose of the service rather than being used to remove an ESRD-related service from the payment bundle.

Weak Documentation of the Separate Condition: The record should clearly establish the unrelated medical problem and why the reported service was required.

Diagnosis and Modifier Conflict: Diagnosis codes suggesting ESRD-related treatment can conflict with AY when the documentation does not explain the distinction.

Assuming AY Guarantees Separate Payment: The modifier identifies the service as unrelated to ESRD but does not independently establish Medicare coverage or reimbursement.

Common Denial Reasons

Service Is Determined to Be ESRD Related: Medicare determines that the reported item or service is part of renal dialysis treatment and therefore does not qualify as unrelated.

Documentation Does Not Support AY: The medical record fails to demonstrate why the item or service was furnished for a condition separate from ESRD treatment.

Service Is Included in the ESRD Bundle: The payer determines that the reported service belongs within the applicable ESRD prospective payment rather than being separately payable.

Diagnosis Information Is Inconsistent: Diagnosis codes and clinical documentation do not support the claim that the reported service was unrelated to ESRD.

Medical Necessity Is Not Supported: Even if the service is unrelated to ESRD, documentation does not establish why the service itself was reasonable and necessary.

Incorrect Claim Reporting: The procedure code, modifier, provider information, or other claim elements do not satisfy applicable Medicare billing requirements.

Modifier AY: ESRD-Related vs. Unrelated Services

The central question when reporting Modifier AY is whether the item or service was furnished for the treatment of ESRD.

An ESRD-related service contributes to the patient's renal dialysis treatment or management and may be included within Medicare's ESRD payment methodology.

An unrelated service addresses a separate medical condition and is not furnished as part of the patient's ESRD treatment. Modifier AY communicates this distinction when applicable.

Documentation should make the clinical reason for the service clear enough to demonstrate why separate treatment and billing are appropriate.

Related Modifiers

Modifier AX

Modifier KX

Modifier GY